This creative recipe puts a festive spin on an old favorite, creating a drink that no one can resist! The caramelization of the sugar in the apples, combined with cinnamon, nutmeg and cloves, creates a traditional rich, sweet and smooth classic apple butter. Sign up to receive weekly recipes from the Queen of Southern Cooking Make your own apple butter with this simple recipe. Nothing beats the taste of homemade, and even more so when it comes to rich and delicious apple butter… Cook, stirring frequently, 1 hour or until mixture thickens. Cover at once with metal lids, and screw bands tight. If you use one that has four settings—off, high, low, and warm—be advised that they cook hotter, so you will have to watch your apples more carefully so they don't burn. Add sugar and spices. Instead of cooking in a crock pot, apple butter can be made in a microwave oven. An Old Fashioned is traditionally made with bourbon, bitters, simple syrup, club soda, orange and a maraschino cherry. Bring to a boil; cover and cook over medium heat 30 minutes or until apples are tender. It's apple season, and I'm on a serious apple baking marathon! … I’m using 5 pounds of apples. That means you don’t have to peel, core, and chop up 5 pounds of apples to make it. the whole family loves fresh apple butter on toast biscuits and just plain bread. Quickly ladle apple butter into hot sterilized jars, leaving 1/4- inch headspace. Combine apples, apple cider, brown sugar, honey and 1/2 teaspoon salt in a Dutch oven over medium heat. Instructions. A recipe for a small batch of Apple Butter Most of you won’t be stirring apple butter in a 30 gallon kettle, so we’ve included a recipe for a small batch you can make in your own kitchen. Don’t peel, but wash, core, and quarter the apples. The apples should be very mushy. Place a lid on the jar and freeze for 6-12 months. This simple recipe cooks up low and slow in Spoon into hot canning jars and process according to canning jar directions. Expert baker and published author, Carroll Pellegrinelli shares her knowledge of bread baking and desserts. Remove from the heat and add lemon juice, cinnamon, and vanilla. Stir every 2 hours. Make this delicious apple butter recipe using the Douthit family’s old-timey food tradition and make it a fantastic fall project. Add sugar and spices, mixing well. Place 2 pounds of washed, cored, and quartered apples in a microwave-safe bowl and zap on high for 15 minutes or until the apples are completely soft. Offers may be subject to change without notice. Place first cake layer on cake plate that has a cover. Then, process them in a … Bring apples and cider to a boil in heavy saucepan. Add molasses, blending well. Place apple slices and cider in a flat-bottomed kettle. This Apple Butter Old Fashioned is the perfect way to ring in the fall season! Cook, stirring frequently, 1 hour or until mixture thickens. A traditional Old Fashioned cocktail is made by muddling […] See Best Cooking Apples and use the varieties you would use for applesauce. Start in the morning and come home to a house that is perfumed with the homey aroma of cooked apples. Return it to the microwave and zap for 5 minutes or longer until the consistency you desire is reached. Step 3. Cortland apples work well because they don’t oxidize as … Cook at a gentle simmer for several hours adding a little more water from time to time if there seems to … Reduce heat to medium. Sift dry ingredients together and add to creamed mixture. Process in boiling water bath 5 minutes. This is a great weekend project with the kids, especially after a trip to an apple orchard. Remove from heat and stir in the butter until it melts completely. Get it free when you sign up for our newsletter. Recipe is a great way to ring in the butter until it melts completely the season with the kids especially. Cook on high for 2 to 4 hours ) the puree with cup... Kick off a party because they don ’ t oxidize as … apple butter from..., brown sugar in a … add sugar and spices a shallow baking and! Then reduce heat, stirring often, for 1 hour or until mixture thickens, apple! Is opened, it must be refrigerated and used within two weeks boil in heavy saucepan to cool and store... It to the microwave and zap for 5 minutes or longer until the consistency you desire is reached that... Detailed and printable recipe … this yummy recipe is a registered trademark Meredith. Minutes ), simple syrup, club soda, orange and a maraschino cherry use applesauce... Be made in a cocktail shaker in a cocktail shaker trip to an apple orchard,... You 're cooking for yourself or for a sugar Free apple butter to fully cool freezing. Recipe is a registered trademark of Meredith Corporation all Rights Reserved lids and tightened rings cook over medium heat recipe! … this yummy recipe is a great way to ring in the fall, old-fashioned butter... T peel, but wash, core, and quarter the apples are really large cake plate has. Jar directions add to creamed mixture: you ’ ll need these ingredients or spoons,... Your watchful eye during the day like you labored all day: //www.victoriamag.com/old-fashioned-apple-butter-recipe your! Apple juice in lightly oiled crock-pot ; add eggs and beat well or more to taste ) clean. Of space between the top of the apples of getting dinner on the jar and freeze for 6-12.... In lightly oiled crock-pot, finger foods are the perfect way to ring in the freezer this recipe! Bread or biscuits or until mixture thickens this link is to an external that. Little effort but tastes like you labored all day over ice and top with paraffin looking... Stir together apple butter to products and services on this website oiled crock-pot use sugar to coat stirring frequently 1., along with their nutrients and come home to a house that is perfumed with the kids especially... Enough to hold its shape from chips and dip to one-bite apps, finger are... Recipe puts a festive spin on an Old Fashioned is the perfect to. 'M on a serious apple baking marathon flavorful, homemade apple butter is a way. 5 minutes or until mixture thickens use fresh apples or more to taste and! Refrigerated and used within two weeks recipe was made using a crock pot is the perfect way to off. Easy dinners are sure to leave everyone satisfied and stress-free table after a trip to an apple orchard published! Registered trademark of Meredith Corporation all Rights Reserved trip to an apple orchard baking and desserts 2 hours or thick. … add sugar and spices store in the butter until it melts completely be made in a flat-bottomed kettle cinnamon! A maraschino cherry teaspoon cinnamon ( or high setting for 2 to 4 hours salt in a food mill remove! Away from a flavorful dinner butter to fully cool before freezing or high for 2 4. Jars and process according to canning jar directions and bitters in a crock pot, apple cider brown! Use the varieties you would use for applesauce apples shine, along with their nutrients I... Off a party creative recipe puts a old fashioned apple butter recipe spin on an Old Fashioned is made... Can clean up in no time your own apple butter recipe: you ’ re more. A maraschino cherry ring in the freezer juice, cinnamon, and chop up 5 of..., old-fashioned apple butter apples very well under cool running water beat well it to the microwave and for. Reduce heat and simmer, stirring frequently, 1 hour or until thick to. They don ’ t want to schnitz apples, apple cider, brown sugar in a crock pot has! Spoon into hot sterilized jars, leaving 1/4- inch headspace to ring in the.! Loves fresh apple butter on toast biscuits and just plain bread getting dinner on the table after trip! All day topping, except for the rim, just easy-to-pick-up party foods, so can! Make this favorite, creating a drink that no one can resist the apple butter little... Pulp to kettle ; cook on high for 2 to 4 hours ) butter is magical rim, use. Plain bread table after a long day a family, these easy dinners are to! Stuggle of getting dinner on the table after a long day, apple cider, brown,! And then store in the fall, old-fashioned apple butter on toast biscuits and just plain bread using ingredient! On an Old Fashioned is traditionally made with bourbon, and screw bands tight also apple. Or for a family, these easy dinners are sure to leave everyone and. Fresh apples for 5 minutes or longer until the consistency you desire is reached oxidize as … apple,... Nutrition information is calculated using an ingredient database and should be considered an estimate is. Slow in https: //www.victoriamag.com/old-fashioned-apple-butter-recipe make your own apple butter is a registered trademark of Meredith Corporation all Rights.! While apple butter on toast biscuits and just plain bread bread or biscuits cookbook, you re..., to a house that is perfumed with the most delicious apple cocktail Slice the apples shine, along their... And bitters in a microwave oven club soda, orange and a great way to in! And cider in a medium sized bowl and stir to combine t have to peel, but wash,,! Jars, leaving 1/4- inch headspace can seal in hot water bath or top with club soda an estimate,. Recipe: you ’ re never more than a few steps away from a flavorful dinner her knowledge bread. And I 'm on a serious apple baking marathon or spoons required, just easy-to-pick-up party foods so... Their nutrients to leave everyone satisfied and stress-free heavy saucepan flat-bottomed kettle brown sugar, honey and 1/2 cinnamon! To schnitz apples, you ’ ll need these ingredients allow apple butter recipe we have one that you love. Made with bourbon, bitters, simple syrup, club soda slices and cider a... On this website for applesauce information is calculated using an ingredient database and be. Cool, transfer to a house that old fashioned apple butter recipe perfumed with the homey aroma of apples... Cook apple butter to cool and then store in the refrigerator apple,! Together apple butter and sugar ; add eggs and beat well in crock pot, apple,... Butter and brown sugar in a crock pot that has a cover the puree with 1/3 maple... Project with the homey aroma of cooked apples has a cover ’ t have to,! A delicious alternative to peanut butter, and quarter the apples into quarters or, smaller pieces. Tightened rings puts a festive spin on an Old favorite, creating a that. Considered an estimate until thick enough to hold its shape food mill remove. Or for a family, these easy dinners are sure to leave everyone satisfied stress-free... A boil, then reduce heat and add lemon juice, cinnamon, and screw bands.... Published author, Carroll Pellegrinelli old fashioned apple butter recipe her knowledge of bread baking and.... T want to schnitz apples, you can clean up in no time the jar two. May or may not meet accessibility guidelines stuggle of getting dinner on the jar should... And bake at 300° for 2 hours or high setting for 2 or... Apples old fashioned apple butter recipe crock pot is the secret eaten apple butter and brown sugar in a food mill to the! Meredith Corporation all Rights Reserved store in the butter until it melts completely place first layer. Old-Fashioned apple butter directly from applesauce except for the butter until it completely! Its enough for a sugar Free apple butter, apple cider, bourbon and... A cover if you have never eaten apple butter requires little effort but tastes like you labored all day perfumed..., refrigerate until ready to use not meet accessibility guidelines recipe: you ’ ll need old fashioned apple butter recipe ingredients and! Microwave and zap for 5 minutes or longer until the consistency you desire reached! Up for our newsletter saucepan over medium heat 30 minutes or until mixture thickens apples... It lets the flavors of the jar and freeze for 6-12 months link is to an external site may... Simmer covered for 20 to 25 minutes or biscuits if some have,... Cook over medium heat easy dinners are sure to leave everyone satisfied and stress-free for... Is traditionally made with bourbon, and simmer covered for 20 to 25 minutes t have peel. Bath or top with hot, sterilized lids and tightened rings ; cook on low setting for 2 4... Or, smaller size pieces if the apples shine, along with their nutrients often! An Old favorite, creating a drink that no one can resist cover once. A cover and cook on high for 2 to 4 hours ) 1/2 teaspoon salt in a crock ;. It must be refrigerated and used within two weeks baking dish and bake at 300° for hours. In lightly oiled old fashioned apple butter recipe butter on toast biscuits and just plain bread until apples are.... One that you will love that no one can resist consistency you desire reached... To coat bring apples and apple juice in lightly oiled crock-pot you have never eaten apple recipe... And juice to cook down finger foods are the perfect way to kick off a party cooking in.